The Deseret News (Salt Lake City, UT)
January 21, 2003, Tuesday
SECTION: LOCAL; Pg. B09
By Lee Davidson
Deseret News Washington correspondent
WASHINGTON -- Protesters weathered a snowstorm and arrests Tuesday
to attack, in part, the pro-cloning-for-research stand of Senate
Judiciary Committee Chairman Orrin Hatch, R-Utah.
U.S. Capitol Police arrested about a dozen peaceful protesters who
refused to stop blocking a door to the Russell Senate Office Building.
They prayed, chanted and gave speeches there, along with about two
dozen other protesters who did not want to be arrested, to attack
Hatch and Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., for not moving
to ban all human cloning. "We're extremely disappointed with
Sen. Orrin Hatch," said the Rev. Patrick Mahoney, director
of the Christian Defense Coalition, which organized the protest.
"I think the mantle that Sen. Orrin Hatch had as a pro-life
champion is gone. Sen. Orrin Hatch is not pro-life on the position
that he has taken," Mahoney said.
Hatch says he opposes cloning when it is designed for reproduction.
But he has joined such liberals as Sens. Ted Kennedy, D-Mass., and
Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., to push to allow exceptions for "therapeutic
cloning" for research.
In it, cloning would create a growing human embryo at the earliest
stages, but development would be stopped after a few days to extract
stem cells or do other research. Hatch and scientists say such research
could be the key to finding cures for everything from Alzheimer's
disease to diabetes and cancer.
Hatch also supports stopping growth in some embryos fertilized in
vitro, which would be otherwise disposed by fertilization clinics,
for stem cell research. Hatch has said he believes a fertilized
human egg is not alive until implanted into the womb of a mother
where it has a chance to grow into a baby.
Protesters disagreed. "Therapeutic cloning is reproductive
cloning," Mahoney said. "For Sen. Hatch, I hope and pray
the good citizens of Utah . . . welcome Sen. Hatch back as a private
citizen the next time he comes up for re-election."
Meanwhile, Mahoney alternatively praised and attacked Frist, who
is a surgeon. "We are very happy that Sen. Frist recognizes
that therapeutic cloning and reproductive cloning are the same animal,
they are exactly the same."
But he complained that Frist has said he will put cloning bans on
the back burner and take up appropriations and tax cut battles first.
Mahoney said protesters chose to block doors to show they feel nothing
should happen until the Senate bans cloning.
The protest came a day before the 30th anniversary of the Supreme
Court's Roe vs. Wade decision that allowed abortion on demand. Pro-life
and pro-choice groups are staging numerous events and demonstrations
around Washington in observance of it.
Among signs held by protesters Tuesday who were attacking Frist
and Hatch were: "Cloning Ends a Human Life," "Embryos
Are Human, Too," "Cloning: Conceived to be Killed,"
and "Life Begins at Conception."