The
Orion Online
|
| Defending the offending
April 30, 2003
The 5-foot-tall pictures of aborted fetuses on campus last week were disturbing. They made me angry. They made me depressed. They made me nauseous. Most importantly, they made me think. Because of the nature of these photos, I began thinking about the nature of free speech. I found those photos to be incredibly offensive, horribly atrocious and otherwise just plain wrong. I strongly disagree with the anti-abortion movement and disagreed even more with this group's idea that abortion is a holocaust and that the women who have abortions are murderers. Yet in spite of these things, I still believe that the religious group that brought those disturbing photos to campus had every right to be there, because I believe that the more controversial the speech, the more that speech needs to be protected. After the shock of seeing the photos wore off, I was more disturbed by the reaction people had toward the photographs than the photos themselves. Passersby that day harassed these people when they came to protest. The Student Activities Office told them to move because they'd received complaints from the women's group that had booked the Free Speech Area. And in one of my classes, a group of women talked about how these people needed to be run off of campus for no other reason than the pictures were offensive. I couldn't believe what I was witnessing. Isn't college supposed to be the sanctuary of liberal thought where people acknowledge all ideas, no matter how controversial? My experience has taught me just the opposite. Some of the people claiming to be the most liberal on campus are the least likely to listen to the positions of another viewpoint. I've seen members of the Progressive Student Union on campus say that we need to censor advertisements because they showed the debasement of women. The Orion has received letters to the editor from members of the same group criticizing us for running a story that showed a conservative point of view. I've also received e-mails from students on campus telling me that I have no right to express my opinion because they were offended by my message. I just don't get it. Yes, those pictures were graphic, but I can't tell you how many classes I've sat through where I've watched "Schindler's List," or actual footage from the holocaust. I've seen gas chambers, piles of dead children and loads of rotting corpses being tossed into pits by heavy machinery. These images are offensive, but I watched them anyway because I realized that seeing these images had something to teach me. Yet students want to censor photos showing other real-life images because they disagree with the message behind them. It doesn't make any sense. Yes, I am pro-choice. I believe that a woman has every right to choose what she does with her body, but doesn't making an intelligent choice involve hearing every point of view? When deciding on a choice as monumental as choosing to have an abortion, shouldn't a woman be allowed to hear both sides of the debate before she commits to such a life-changing action? I saw those images and I wasn't convinced that abortion is wrong. But it did get me thinking. Isn't that kind of thought what college is all about? Too often in our society the First Amendment is thrown out the window because we disagree with what is being said, when we really should be alarmed whenever anyone wants to censor what we see. When we're the most offended by a message and are ready to remove it from the public eye, we need to remember the words of the French philosopher Voltaire: "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it." Ryan Sabalow can be reached at: rsabalow@orion-online.net http://www.orion-online.net/vnews/display.v/ART/2003/04/30/3eaefff3eac20?in_archive=1 |