Free speech?
Anti-abortion group's posters disturb Women's Center
event, upset students
Rosalio Ahumada
Assistant News Editor
April 30, 2003
An anti-abortion group was forced to leave the Free
Speech Area after its graphic posters alarmed audience
members at a Women's Center event last week.
The group, called Survivors of the Abortion Holocaust,
stood on the sidewalks surrounding the Free Speech
Area on April 22 for about 20 minutes before students
started confronting them.
The four-foot poster boards with pictures of aborted
fetuses were what really grabbed everyone's attention.
The posters included a picture of a fetus aborted
in the third trimester of pregnancy, a procedure only
performed in emergency situations.
Victoria Soria, member of the Christian pro-life
group, admitted that the pictures were horrifying,
but they want to show college students, especially
women, what an abortion really is.
"A lot of girls we talked to after they had
the abortions did not know what the procedure was
going to be like," Soria said.
She said she talks to many women at the pregnancy
crisis center where she works. Soria said the women
did not know of the emotional and physical effects
of an abortion until after they had the procedure.
Emily Ruffridge, a Chico State senior, thought the
pictures went too far and said she was horribly offended.
"I should not be harassed like this," Ruffridge
said. "They make people feel like they're horrible
creatures."
Ruffridge was the first student to confront the anti-abortion
group. She had been listening to speakers at "Breaking
the Silence" when she saw the anti-abortion group
standing with large pictures and handing out fliers.
The event, which was raising awareness of domestic
violence, hate crimes, child abuse and violence against
the earth, was sponsored by the Women's Center and
EARC.
Liliana Blanco, one of the organizers of "Breaking
the Silence," said they never complained about
the anti-abortion group. By the time they approached
university officials, the situation was already being
handled, she said.
Blanco said she didn't oppose the anti-abortion group's
right to free speech, but she didn't want any negativity
around the area they had reserved.
"We were trying to create a safe place for people
to come and discuss these issues," Blanco said.
"That picture alone brought nothing but negativity."
She said any other day the anti-abortion group would've
been allowed to stay there.
Ruffridge's dispute with the group lasted a few minutes.
She said she didn't understand why the group was there
and that they were just disrupting a positive day.
"You know how many people you're horrifying
with this," Ruffridge told Soria. "You guys
shouldn't be out here with this sign and telling women
what they should do with their bodies."
Soria told Ruffridge they weren't shouting out slogans
or speaking to anyone unless spoken to first. She
said all they were doing was handing out fliers and
displaying the pictures.
During the heated discussion, Soria's fellow group
members had already walked up, grabbed the poster
board and moved to another area. The Los Angeles-based
group had around 10 people traveling with them that
day. According to the group's Web site, 18-year-olds
to 29-year-olds are paid up to $600 a month to tour
campuses and present their pro-life stance.
They travel to universities and high school campuses
across the nation. They were headed to a Chico high
school later that day.
"A majority of abortions happen to college-age
and high school-age women," Soria said. "That's
the main target of the abortion industry."
The group set up their poster boards in front of
the Bell Memorial Union food court, but it was only
a few minutes before a group of students confronted
them there. Rick Rees, associate director of Student
Activities, approached the group and told them they
had to move farther away from the Free Speech Area.
He said he received complaints from students and
told the anti-abortion group to leave the campus.
Rees said since the Women's Center and EARC had reserved
the area, other groups weren't allowed to disrupt
their event.
"It's a way to protect free speech," Rees
said. "They can't disrupt your rights to freedom
of expression."
Rees compromised with the anti-abortion group and
allowed them to set-up just north of Meriam Library,
but they left the campus an hour later.
He said universities have the right and the duty
to regulate the time and place for free speech. Rees
said the anti-abortion group never notified the university
that they would be there.
"If you come to somebody's place of business
or education, you should let them know," Rees
said. "I don't know of any campus that allows
you to have events just anywhere."
Rosalio Ahumada can be reached at:
rahumada@orion-online.net
http://www.orion-online.net/vnews/display.v/ART/2003/04/30/3eaf131641153?in_archive=1
|